Our DV-2003 adjustment of status experience.

NOTICE: I'm NOT a lawyer and this webpage does NOT offer legal advice or legal opinions on any specific matters. Anybody using any information on this webpage is doing so at his/her own risk.

We were selected in the diversity visa lottery (DV-2003). We applied for adjustment of status (AOS) in Chicago. After two unnecessary visits to Chicago District USCIS (a.k.a. INS, BCIS, CIS) we obtained a fingerprinting appointment and an interview appointment. At the interview we were told that our status will be adjusted when our background checks clear. We tried to expedite our background checks for seven months. We sent inquiry to BCIS. We visited Chicago BCIS office and inquired in person several times. We contacted our Senators and Representative who in turn contacted BCIS. All these efforts turned out to be futile. Then a lawsuit was filed. Our status was adjusted within a week of the filing. The AOS would be denied without the lawsuit. For the entire time BCIS maintained that the delay was caused by security checks. This turned out to be a lie - the reason, as some documents on this page show, was mishandling of our case by BCIS.

Judging from the experiences of other people in DV-2003 and DV-2004 it was not wise to wait with the lawsuit that long; it should have been filed much earlier - probably mid August, maybe even earlier. The reason is that many judges will give government time to settle matters without a formal order and then will be reluctant to issue the order on 30th of September (as happened in 04-cv-1627). A judge might be more likely to issue an order if he/she sees that the government did not act in good faith for an extended period of time (as happened in 03-cv-3303).

All the gory details of the case can be found in sections Lottery, Application, Follow-up, Lawsuit(s) below. Included is our communication with BCIS and the result of later FOIPA requests. There is other interesting material on this page: docket sheets for nine DV-2003 related lawsuits filed in 2003 (there were more such lawsuits - the selection covers only 3 out of 94 federal district courts); hearing transcripts for four of these lawsuits; links to court opinions in relevant precedential cases and links to message boards and pages containing useful information.

You can find some interesting information on this page even if you are doing AOS not based on the visa lottery. It is likely that USCIS lies about security checks (i.e., tries to blame the delays on security checks) in these cases too. Filing a lawsuit is definitely an option (see e.g., 04-CV-4575).

    These three documents are interesting:

    • letter from Chicago BCIS District Director Donald J. Monica to Senator Richard J. Durbin dated 06/06/03;
    • letter from Chicago BCIS District Director Donald J. Monica to Senator Richard J. Durbin dated 08/15/03;
    • document from our BCIS file stating that our FBI name check was requested by BCIS on 08/28/03, received by BCIS on 09/10/03 and looked at by BCIS on 09/18/03.

    The letters of Donald J. Monica imply that FBI name check was requested by BCIS much earlier than 08/28/03. Our BCIS file suggests that FBI name check was NOT requested by BCIS until 08/28/03.

    The discrepancy was pointed out to DHS Inspector General, USCIS Office of Internal Audit and Donald J. Monica with request for public explanation on 12/06/03. To date no explanation was received.

    This leads me to believe that the information in the letters of Donald J. Monica was false. If district director provides false information to Senator then what quality of information should people expect to get from the USCIS information officers?


If you have problems viewing documents on this page see technical info.

Acknowledgement


Lottery

Application

Interview


Follow-up


Lawsuit(s)

There were more (e.g. 03-CV-3303, 03-CV-4677, 03-CV-1855) such cases filed in 2003. You can get more information using US Party Index search. Here are some search results: Eduardo Aguirre, Thomas Ridge, BCIS, Donald J. Monica, all 540/890 lawsuits in ilndc in Sep'03.

There were some lawsuits in 2004 as well.

If you want to check whether such lawsuits were done in your district you can get a PACER account. Then you can search for lawsuits where the defendant is the Interim District Director at that time (see the list ). As you can see from the searches you might miss some cases.

The docket sheets were obtained using PACER. Apendices from the complaints were removed to protect privacy of the plaintiffs. For more information about privacy and public access to electronic case files see Judicial Conference Privacy Policy. The transcripts were obtained from the appropriate court reporters. Many thanks to those who sponsored the purchase of the transcripts.

The actual number of visas issued in DV-2003 was 50,712

U.S. Department of State Visa Bulletin, Number 73, Volume VIII contains a wealth of statistical information about DV-2003. According to the information in the bulletin 48,115 diversity visas were issued by embassies and consulates. USCIS Yearbook of Immigration Statistics 2003 provides information about immigration to U.S. in general. According to the yearbook 2,597 people became permanent residens by adjustment of status based on DV-2003. Thus 50,712 diversity visas were issued in DV-2003. The limit, as given by Section 203(c) of the INA together with NACARA, for DV-2003 was 50,000.

Info about lawyers

Following is the list of lawsuits in the appropriate federal district courts returned by em/cf/pacer/racer for the attorneys mentioned on this page:


Aftermath


Court opinions


Links


Misc


Other Interesting Cases

Other interesting case (citizenship):
It seems that lawyers in Chicago finally realized that sometimes the only way to deal with Chicago USICS is to file a lawsuit:

Technical Info

Inquire

Usage Statistics


Search Engine Keywords

DV-2003 problems DV 2003 story mishandled diversity visa lottery 2003 CIS affirmative misconduct BCIS INS USCIS problems applied apply application processing legal options class action lawsuit mandamus delay delays security checks background checks FBI name check CIA name check IBIS check dv story caselaw adjustment of status AOS writ of mandamus chicago district office issues green card permanent resident permanent residency FOIA FOIPA PACER information litigation congressman Representative Senator I-485 form forum case is pending immigration lawyer lawyers AILA AILF chicago adjudication office interview officer deadline is September 30th end of fiscal year federal district court approved adjusted delayed inquiry expedite processing screw-up bureau of citizenship and immigration service Paunescu v. INS Nyaga v. INS Iddir v. INS denied moot relief consular processing discretionary mandatory adjudicated expired mootness removal eligibility alien winner eligible subject matter jurisdiction administrative remedies remedy Michael M. Comfort Michael Comfort mcm mcm:ara mmc:ka Donald J. Monica Donald Monica djm:gl SDAO Carissa Cohen cc SDAO Marilyn Roraff Marilyn J. Roraff Switalski Coleman DAO N. D. Larkins ndl N. Larkins DAO Jesse Fernandez Klinger Baylas Janis S. Sposato jss Janis Sposato pro se motion injunctive relief summons DV-2004 DV-2005 DV-2006 Bureau of Citizenship and Immigration Services BCIS United States Citizenship and Immigration Services USCIS US Citizenship and Immigration Services US CIS C.I.S. U.S.C.I.S C. I. S. U. S. C. I. S. Immigration and Naturalization Service INS I. N. S. I.N.S. DJM:hml DJM:drw expedite Janice B. Podolny jbp Janice Podolny William R. Yates wry William Yates (22nd july 1999 memo in 04-4140) Mary Ann Gantner mag Mary Gantner DAO Roberto Garby rg Judith G. Patterson lgp Judith Patterson David L. Roark dlr David Roark Kenneth L. Pasquarell klp Kenneth Pasquarell Lesley E. Leger-Kelley lel lelk Lesley Leger-Kelley Lesley Elizabeth Leger-Kelley Fujie Ohata Karen L. Potosnak klp Karen Potosnak Pauline A. Appelbaum paa Pauline Appelbaum Cheri Lynn Jones clj William D. Craig wdc William Craig Doug Charles W. Oppenheim co cwo Charles Oppenheim Sheila M. Entenman Sheila Entenman Craig A. Oswald Craig Oswald Timothy Maguire Roslynn R. Mauskopf Roslynn Mauskopf Michael T. Shelby Michael Shelby Howard E. Rose Howard Rose 50712 diversity visas issued in DV-2003 50,712 diversity lottery visas issued in DV-2003 DAO Demitria Wright dw Law Offices of S. Bernard Schwarz will screw your DV case, 381 Park Avenue South, Suite 619, New York Chicago immigration lawyers Dianne Padilla Scott M. Beller David Lehman Susan Fortino-Brown Patricia Hindo Therese M. Yee Stephen Berman Scott D. Pollock Margaret H. McCormick Dolly Warden Lisa Palumbo Lisa Nosek Kalman D. Resnick Douglas Gottfried Carlina Tapia-Ruano Robert R. Gard Terry Yale Feirtag Julia A. Rice Diana C. Bauerle Richard Hanus Paul Djurisic Susan Compernolle Duane F. Sigelko Stephen Berman Alex Elsberg Julie Harcum Heather Barbus Elizabeth L. Krueger, P.C. Wheaton, IL "Immigration Law Practice for Business and Individual Clients" Law Offices of Ronald Shapiro, Ltd. Fisher & Phillips LLP Law Office of O'Grady & Associates, P.C. Susan Fortino-Brown Mark S. Kocol, Attorney at Law Davidson & Schiller, LLC Law Offices of Richard Hanus Mandel, Lipton and Stevenson Limited Vedder, Price, Kaufman & Kammholz Michael Best & Friedrich LLP Quarles & Brady LLP Barnes & Thornburg LLP Barbosa Law Group, P.C. Immigration Law Associates, P.C. Michael B. Dedio, P.C. Attorneys Serving You, LLC Law Offices of Shanshan Zhou Whitcup & Arce, P.C. Ellen D. Krengel Ltd. Law Office of Li Nan Chiang Gostynska Frakt, Ltd. Alexander C. Vrbanoff Hsieh, Nathaniel K. Kriezelman & Associates Immigration Legal & Consulting Services PC Stephen F. Potts Mosteller & Holmberg, P.C. Law Office of Theresa V. Johnson Steven H. Mevorah & Assoc. Law Offices of Ronald Shapiro, Ltd. Wolfe & Associates Steven H. Mevorah & Assoc. Elizabeth L. Krueger, P.C. Mercedes Jaile, LLC Law Offices of Shirley Sadjadi Law Offices of Richard Hanus Leshen & Sliwinski, P.C. Johnson Law Group Howard & Howard Attorneys, P.C. Kevin N. McDermott, Attorney Kevin N. McDermott, Attorney Law Office of Brian Dees Blackwell Sanders Peper Martin LLP Williams Law Firm Polaris Legal Solutions Law Offices of Ashley Dworsky Metcalf & Associates, P.C. Law Offices of Neal Connors